Returns, Exchanges and Refunds

Returns, Exchanges and Refunds

Our principal objective is to maintain the highest level of customer satisfaction and integrity, and we definitely welcome any customer suggestions and recommendations regarding your experience with CRAIG SHELLY FINE JEWELRY & WATCHES.  Please call us at 1.909.803.0981


Return Process (10 Day Return)

1. Generate Return Authentication Code:

Call 909-803-0981 to obtain the Return Authentication Code (RAC).

If your order has more than one product, please generate separate Return Authentication Code (RAC) for each product.

Each Return Authentication Code (RAC) has a validity period. Please ensure that we receive the Returns within the validity period. We will not accept the Returns after the validity period.

2. Prepare Your Return Package:

Package your return and remember to include all original packaging material. Please write the Return Authentication Code (RAC) on the outside of the box you are returning.

3. Ship It:

Insure the package and ship it to:




(Please note that FedEx and UPS will only insure packages up to $500. For items worth more than $500, please ship your package through USPS, insured for the total value of the contents.)

{No refund will be issued on custom orders and watches. Only merchandise credit will be offered.}



Loose Diamond 3 Day Return Policy

Returns on our loose diamonds, rings made using “design your ring” feature, pre-set engagement and wedding rings, custom jewelry, custom jewelry with a center diamond or a gemstone, are a bit different. Since our prices on the loose diamonds are the LOWEST on the web, we rarely have anyone wanting to return a diamond purchased from our site. To maintain our competitiveness, all Certified Loose Diamond purchases come with a 7 Day Money Back Guarantee. If for any reason you are not satisfied with your Certified Loose Stone purchase or with your customized setting, you have 7 days from date of receipt to obtain an RAC Number and return the item to us. Receiving RAC number alone doesn’t mean that the item can be returned after 7 days. The Warehouse must receive the item within 7 days of original delivery date in order to receive a full refund. All Certified Stones must be returned with the original Diamond Gemological Grading Certificate and appraisal. Returns that are not accompanied by the original certificate will be subject to a certification replacement fee ranging between $200 and $10,000.

To return a diamond or jewelry item to CRAIG SHELLY FINE JEWELRY & WATCHES, please follow the below shown process:

  • For US Customers, call 1.909.803.0981 for a Return Authorization Code (RAC CODE).
  • For security purpose, please do not write the word(s) diamond & or & jewelry on your package.
  • Place all the original packaging in the box, including the appraisal and the diamond certificate. 
  • If you have received any free gift along with the purchase, it must be returned too. No refund will be made otherwise.

On your invoice, if the price of the item you’re returning is listed as:

  • Less than $500: You can ship it via any carrier. Be sure to ship your item fully insured, and request a return receipt with an adult signature for confirmation that your shipment has reached its destination and is signed by the receiver. 
  • More than $500: Ship your package via US Postal Service Registered Mail™, insured for the total value of the contents, and request a return receipt  with a proof of signature from the receiver for confirmation that your shipment has reached CRAIG SHELLY FINE JEWELRY & WATCHES. * (FedEx® and UPS® will not insure merchandise over $500.)
  • All the returns should be mailed to:

12477 North Main Street
Rancho Cucamonga, CA 91739

Once your return is received, CRAIG SHELLY FINE JEWELRY & WATCHES Quality Assurance department will review it. You will receive e-mail notification regarding your return or exchange within seven business days.

Any unauthorized, improperly packaged, or non-insured packages will be returned to sender. Items that show signs of wear or have been resized or altered (by a jeweler other than CRAIG SHELLY FINE JEWELRY & WATCHES), engraved, altered, or damaged in any way cannot be accepted or processed for return.

If you have any questions about our return procedure, please don’t hesitate to contact us.

Call us: 1.909.803.0981 

We are always open to gladly assist you between 9:00AM to 6:00PM (PST), Mon-Fri

* CRAIG SHELLY FINE JEWELRY & WATCHES will not be responsible for loss or damage of return shipments.




Sales Tax

Since CRAIG SHELLY FINE JEWELRY & WATCHES is based in California, state law requires that we charge sales tax (8.00%) on orders delivered to customers in California.

To customers residing in states other than California, please be aware that, if applicable, the taxing authorities in your state may charge you a “use” tax on your out-of-state internet and/or catalog purchases. While it is not the responsibility of CRAIG SHELLY FINE JEWEWLRY & WATCHES to charge or collect this “use” tax from you at this time, we are alerting our customers regarding this possibility as a courtesy. If you require further information on this issue, we suggest you contact the tax authorities in your state directly.

Craig Shelly